- Worldwide analysis of nearly 6 million deaths from COVID-19 over 2 years finds an increase in COVID-19 mortality at weekends compared to weekdays.
- Findings are unlikely to reflect just bureaucratic and reporting delays but also shortfalls in hospital capacity, clinical staffing and expertise, researchers say.
- Among ten countries with the highest COVID-19 counts, the USA, Brazil, and the UK had significantly higher deaths on Saturday and Sunday compared to weekdays throughout the pandemic.
- This “weekend effect” was not seen in Germany, where more COVID-related deaths were reported on weekdays.
Embargo: 2301H UK time Saturday 16 April 2022
The average number of global deaths from COVID-19 were 6% higher on weekends compared to weekdays (8,532 vs 8,083) throughout the pandemic, according to new research analysing all deaths reported to the WHO COVID-19 database between March 7, 2020 and March 7, 2022. The study is by Dr. Fizza Manzoor and Dr. Donald Redelmeier from the University of Toronto, Canada.
The findings, to be presented at this year’s European Congress of Clinical Microbiology & Infectious Diseases (ECCMID) in Lisbon, Portugal (23-26 April), reveal that the highest absolute increase in weekend COVID-19 deaths was in the USA (average 1,483 weekend deaths vs 1,220 weekday deaths, 22% increase), followed by Brazil (1,061 vs 823, 29% increase), and the UK (239 vs 215, 11% increase). Only Germany reported significantly fewer average deaths at weekends compared to weekdays (137 vs 187; see figures in notes to editors).
For the study, researchers calculated the average number of deaths on weekends compared to the average number of deaths that occurred on the preceding Monday to Friday (weekdays). They then repeated the analyses for 10 countries with the highest COVID-19 cases: the USA, UK, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Russia, India, Brazil, and Canada. Analyses were adjusted for national holidays ad long weekends.
A total of 5,983,471 deaths and 444,961,484 new cases were identified over the two years. Researchers found that, worldwide there were on average 449 more COVID-19 deaths on weekends than weekdays (8,532 vs 8,083).
Because healthcare system performance and awareness improved during the pandemic, researchers performed a more detailed evaluation comparing weekend deaths in the earlier half (March 2020 to March 2021) to the latter half (March 2021 to March 2022), and discovered that the increase in weekend deaths remained significant over the 2 years—with an average 641 additional weekend deaths (7,825 vs 7,184) in the first year compared with an average 257 additional weekend deaths (9,239 vs 8,982) in the second.
Further analyses looking at the average number of COVID-19 deaths on individual days of the week, found that the increase was particularly large when comparing Sunday to Monday (8,850 vs 7,219 deaths) and Friday to Monday (9,086 vs 7,219). The other weekdays showed no particular trend in average number of deaths (Tuesday 6,825; Wednesday 8,070; Thursday 9,230). Additionally, the average number of COVID-19 deaths on the two weekend days were also dissimilar (Saturday 8,850, Sunday 8,071).
“Bureaucratic delays on weekends alone do not explain why there are fewer documented COVID-19 deaths on Mondays compared to Fridays, and reporting lags alone cannot explain why the increase in weekend deaths was so substantial in the USA and not seen in Germany”, says Dr Manzoor. “Instead, the ‘weekend effect’ is also likely to be due to shortfalls in clinical staffing, capacity, and experience. What’s more, our findings suggest that this problem is not resolving despite improved health system performance and awareness over the course of the pandemic. There is an opportunity for health systems to further improve clinical care on all days of the week.”
She adds, “Further studies, with detailed clinical data are needed to investigate the drivers of and causes for the risk of death on weekdays and weekends from COVID-19.”
Despite these important findings, the authors note that the study could be limited by false negative results, missed cases, and data entry errors, which may affect the conclusions that can be drawn. Additionally, the available data do not account for disease severity or capture the nuanced differences in the microbiologic, systemic, and social factors affecting each separate wave of the pandemic. Finally, the results do not explore the impact of local policies and public health interventions in individual countries.
Notes to editors:
This article was supported by a Canada Research Chair in Medical Decision Sciences.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
This press release is based on late breaking poster abstract L0386 (abstract number 4876) at the European Congress of Clinical Microbiology & Infectious Diseases (ECCMID). All accepted abstracts have been extensively peer reviewed by the congress selection committee. There is no full paper at this stage, but the authors are happy to answer your questions. The research has been submitted to a medical journal for publication.
For full PDF of submitted study, containing figures and tables, click here
(Note this updates the abstract, so the abstract is not supplied)
For full poster click here
Selected media coverage
Sky News (international)
Yahoo News (international)
France 24 (France)
The West Australian (Australia)